Editorial standards
Every page on Content Runbook follows these rules. A page that breaks one doesn’t get published.
Every fact has a source
Every number, quote, date, and claim about a product links to its source or comes from our own logged data. When we can’t verify something, we leave it out.
We define established professional terms, like content brief or editorial calendar, in our own words. When a term has an originator or an official definition, such as generative engine optimization or Google’s names for its own features, we cite that source.
We say what we tested
We only say “we tested” when we ran the test ourselves, and we publish what we did and where the test falls short. Tool lists carry one of two labels:
- Researched: built from each tool’s own pages, checked on the date shown. No hands-on claims and no ratings that imply testing.
- Tested: the same task run through every tool, scored on a published rubric, with the scores and test dates shown.
When we publish original data, we publish the method, the raw counts, and what the data can’t tell you.
How we use AI
AI helps us research, draft, and check pages. A person reviews and approves every page before it goes live and owns every editorial decision. Editing may cut or restructure a draft but never adds a fact, name, number, or quote that isn’t in the sources. We don’t edit to get past AI detectors.
No invented people
We don’t invent authors, experts, quotes, testimonials, reviews, or case-study clients. We publish as Content Runbook, and the about page explains why and how we work.
Every page adds something
We don’t publish a page unless it adds something the pages already ranking don’t: our own data, a test we ran, a template, or a process we use. More words on the same points don’t count.
Independence
We don’t sell AI tools or agency services. No vendor can pay for a place on a list, a position on it, or a review. Picks in researched lists follow the stated evidence, rankings in tested lists follow the scores, and a tool without an affiliate program stays on a list whenever the evidence picks it. Pages with affiliate links say so near the top; see our affiliate disclosure.
Updates
Every page shows the date it was last reviewed. We recheck researched tool lists every quarter, retest tested lists twice a year, and update data pages after each new round.
Corrections
When we get something wrong, we fix it and note the correction on the page with the date and what changed, as on our citation study. If you spot an error, tell us.